Skip to content
Trumbull, CT · Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm
Total BizSolutions LLC
Decision Guide

When an S Corp Election Starts Making Sense for a Fairfield, CT Business

The S corp question is really a salary question. How reasonable pay, payroll, the extra return and Connecticut's yearly choice decide whether it pays.

Published Updated 8 min readBy Total BizSolutions LLC
An editorial illustration of a desk with a payroll stub, a tax form and a calculator side by side.
Summarize this with AI

The short answer

An S corp election starts paying when your profit runs clearly past a fair salary for the work you do, year after year, and the leftover is big enough to cover the extra admin. Below that point it mostly adds paperwork.

Two Fairfield owners with the same revenue can land on opposite sides of this. A one-person consultancy billing its own hours from a home office in Greenfield Hill has very little profit that isn't really wages. A small shop on the Post Road with two staff and its own equipment may have plenty.

The rules below are as the IRS and Connecticut DRS publish them, checked in November 2026. The decision itself belongs in a conversation with your own preparer, using your own numbers.

What does an S corp election actually change?

It changes how the business is taxed, not what it does. The IRS page on S corporations says they pass income, losses, deductions and credits through to their shareholders, who report them on their personal returns. To become one, the business files Form 2553 signed by all its shareholders.

An LLC can get there too. The IRS LLC page says a single-member LLC is disregarded for income tax by default and a multi-member LLC is a partnership, and the Form 2553 instructions say an eligible entity that meets the S corporation tests is treated as a corporation from its effective date without filing Form 8832 separately.

As a sole proprietor, your net earnings carry self-employment tax, which the IRS self-employment tax page puts at 15.3%, with the Social Security part capped at a yearly wage base. In an S corp, the IRS compensation page says wages are subject to employment taxes and non-wage distributions are not. That split is the whole appeal, and it's also the catch.

What counts as a reasonable salary?

Whatever someone would fairly be paid for the work you actually do in the business. The same IRS compensation page says an S corporation must pay reasonable compensation to a shareholder-employee for their services before non-wage distributions can be made, and that the IRS can reclassify distributions as wages.

IRS fact sheet FS-2008-25 says there are no specific guidelines for reasonable compensation in the Code or the Regulations, and that courts decide on the facts of each case. The factors it lists include training and experience, duties and responsibilities, time and effort devoted to the business, and what comparable businesses pay for similar services.

The IRS compensation page also says to look at where the gross receipts come from. Receipts generated by your own personal services point to wages. Receipts generated by non-shareholder employees, or by capital and equipment, can properly go out as distributions. That's why the Greenfield Hill consultant and the Post Road shop come out so differently.

So when does it start making sense?

When the part of your profit that isn't pay for your own work is large and steady. The IRS publishes no profit figure for this, so here's how the usual situations line up instead.

S corp election by situation, for a small business owner
Your situationWhat drives the answerWorth raising with your preparer
Profit is about what a fair salary for your role would beMost receipts come from your own hoursOften too little to gain yet
Profit runs well past a fair salary, year after yearPart of the profit comes from staff, equipment or capitalWorth running the numbers properly
Profit swings a lot from one year to the nextA salary that holds up is hard to setWait for a steadier year or plan carefully
You're forming the business nowThe first-year filing window starts on day oneRaise it before the window closes
An owner is a partnership, a corporation or a nonresident alienIRS eligibility testsThe election isn't open as things stand

The last row comes from the Form 2553 instructions, which say an electing corporation can have no more than 100 shareholders, only individuals, estates, certain trusts and certain exempt organizations as shareholders, and no nonresident alien shareholders.

Best for: profit that clearly outruns a fair wage for the owner's role, and an owner ready to run payroll. Not for: a business still finding its level, or profit that's mostly the owner's own hours.

Weighing the S corp election?

Call (267) 710-6742 and we'll go through last year's numbers with you.

Call (267) 710-6742

What does the election add to your admin?

Payroll, a second return, and a commitment that's slow to undo. FS-2008-25 says corporate officers are employees for FICA, FUTA and federal income tax withholding, so your own salary goes through payroll. If you've never run payroll, our first-employee payroll setup guide covers the Connecticut registrations, and payroll services covers the monthly work.

The IRS S corporations page lists Form 1120-S for the business, with a Schedule K-1 for each shareholder, and Schedule E on the shareholder's own 1040. That's two returns to prepare each year, and tax preparation for an S corp owner covers both returns.

Getting out isn't instant. The Form 2553 instructions say the election stays in effect until it's terminated or revoked, and that IRS consent is generally needed for a new election before the 5th tax year after the first tax year the termination took effect.

What changes on the Connecticut side?

Mostly one extra yearly choice. Connecticut DRS's pass-through entity tax page, last updated December 15, 2025, says the Pass-Through Entity Tax is optional, that an entity choosing it has to elect each year, and that the election is irrevocable. The page says a partnership or S corporation makes it by checking a box on a timely filed Form CT-1065/CT-1120SI.

Whether electing helps depends on the owners' own returns, so it belongs in the same conversation as the federal decision.

When do you file Form 2553?

Before the window for the year you want closes. The Form 2553 instructions say to file no more than 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year the election is to take effect, or at any time during the tax year before it. The IRS example for an established calendar-year corporation ends that window on March 15.

A new business has a narrower start. The same instructions say the 2-month period runs from the day the first tax year begins, and an election made before that day isn't valid. If you're forming the business now, new business formation is the point to settle this. A late election generally takes effect the following tax year, and the instructions describe relief that may be available where the delay had reasonable cause.

How do you test it on your own numbers?

Here's the test worth running with your preparer. Take last year's actual profit and set a fair salary for your role against it, using the IRS factors above. Compare the employment tax on that salary with your self-employment tax as things stand, then subtract what payroll and a second return cost to run. If what's left is thin, or rests on a salary that would be hard to defend, that's usually a sign to wait.

Our Fairfield page covers the wider bookkeeping and tax work for owners in town. Total BizSolutions works from Trumbull, which borders Fairfield, and serves small businesses in Connecticut and throughout the United States. Get in touch if you'd like to go through the numbers before you file.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a profit level where an S corp always makes sense?

No. It depends on what a fair salary for your role looks like, how much profit sits above it, and what the extra payroll and returns cost you to run. Your own numbers decide it, not a figure from an article.

Can a single-member LLC make the S corp election?

Often, yes, if it meets the eligibility tests. The section on when the election starts making sense lists those tests, with links to the IRS pages.

Can I undo the election if it doesn't work out?

You can end it, but switching back and forth isn't quick. There's a waiting period before a new election without IRS consent, covered in the admin section above, so plan on living with it for a while.

Does the election change anything on the Connecticut side?

Yes. The business has a yearly Connecticut choice to make, covered in the Connecticut section above. It belongs in the same conversation as the federal decision.

Do you only work with businesses in Fairfield?

No. Total BizSolutions is based in Trumbull, Connecticut, next to Fairfield, and offers tax planning, payroll and bookkeeping to small businesses across Connecticut and throughout the United States.

Want the numbers handled properly?

Bookkeeping, QuickBooks, payroll, tax and IRS help for small businesses, from our office in Trumbull, Connecticut, and for clients throughout the United States through a secure client portal.

Books, payroll and tax from one office.

Bookkeeping, QuickBooks, payroll, tax and IRS help for small businesses, from our office in Trumbull, Connecticut, and for clients throughout the United States through a secure client portal.

Call NowContact Us